Navigating Recruiting Myths, Pitfalls, and Pet Peeves

Making the wrong step or misstep in the college recruiting process can be compared to navigating the treacherous obstacles in the classic Atari game Pitfall. In both scenarios, a single misjudgment can lead to costly consequences and setbacks.

Just as in Pitfall, where the player must carefully navigate hazards like quicksand, rolling logs, and crocodile-infested waters, prospective college athletes must navigate a complex and competitive recruitment landscape. Taking the wrong step, such as choosing the wrong college to pursue or neglecting academic requirements, can have significant repercussions.


"Pitfall Harry once wisely remarked, 'In the perilous journey of life, be it through treacherous jungles or the college recruiting maze, success lies in anticipating and avoiding the dangers ahead. Take each step with purpose, for a misstep can cost more than just progress—it can cost the opportunity of a lifetime.'"


In Pitfall, falling into a pit or colliding with an obstacle means losing valuable time and progress. Similarly, in the college recruiting process, a misstep may result in missed opportunities, such as not being recruited by preferred colleges or losing out on potential scholarship opportunities. Timing is crucial in both scenarios. Just as the player in Pitfall needs to time their jumps and swings perfectly to avoid dangers, student-athletes must be strategic in their approach to college recruitment. Waiting too long to start the process or making decisions impulsively can lead to missed opportunities and regrettable outcomes.


In both Pitfall and the college recruiting process, there is often a limited window of opportunity. Missing deadlines, underestimating the importance of standardized tests, or failing to maintain academic eligibility can close doors for prospective student-athletes.


Ultimately, the comparison highlights the importance of careful planning, strategic decision-making, and precise execution in both navigating Pitfall's hazards and successfully maneuvering through the college recruiting process. Just as in the game, where a misstep can lead to setbacks, in the college recruitment journey, a well-thought-out approach is crucial to avoid costly mistakes and secure a successful outcome.


The recruiting process can be a daunting journey for athletes and their families as they strive to find the right fit for their academic and athletic future.  However, navigating through the myths, pitfalls, and pet peeves that often accompany the recruiting process can significantly impact the outcome.  Understanding what makes coaches tick, while avoiding common misconceptions and missteps, is crucial for making the most of your recruiting experience.  In this article, we'll explore some prevalent myths, pitfalls to avoid, and strategies for optimizing your recruiting journey.


Recruiting Myths

  1. "Only Division I Schools Offer Athletic Scholarships": Contrary to this belief, all three NCAA divisions, as well as NAIA and junior colleges, can offer athletic scholarships. Student-athletes should explore a variety of institutions that align with their academic and athletic goals.
  2. "Recruiters Will Find Me if I'm Talented Enough": While exceptional talent is crucial, relying solely on natural abilities can be a pitfall. Proactive self-promotion, engagement with coaches, and participating in recruiting events are essential for increasing visibility.
  3. "Athletic Performance Trumps Academic Achievements": Balancing academics and athletics is crucial for student-athletes. College recruiters often seek well-rounded individuals who can excel both on the field and in the classroom.
  4. "Full Scholarships are Common for All Athletes": Full athletic scholarships are rare, especially outside of high-profile sports. Many student-athletes receive a combination of athletic, academic, and need-based aid. Understanding the nuances of financial packages is crucial.
  5. "Only the Superstars Get Recruited": College recruiters often look for athletes who demonstrate potential, commitment, and a good fit for their program. Many successful student-athletes may not be widely known but still make valuable contributions to college teams.


Pitfalls to Avoid

Navigating the college recruiting process as a student-athlete can be complex and competitive. To ensure a smoother journey, it's essential to be aware of potential pitfalls. Here are the top five pitfalls to avoid in the college recruiting process for student-athletes:


  1. Procrastination in Starting the Process:
  • Pitfall: Waiting until the last minute to initiate the recruiting process can limit opportunities and scholarship options.
  • Solution: Begin early by researching colleges, creating a comprehensive athletic and academic profile, and reaching out to coaches during your high school years.


2. Overlooking Academic Preparation:

  • Pitfall: Focusing solely on athletic development and neglecting academics can hinder eligibility for college sports and limit scholarship opportunities.
  • Solution: Maintain a strong academic record, take required standardized tests seriously, and ensure eligibility by understanding and meeting academic requirements for college athletics.


3. Ignoring Fit for the Sake of Prestige:

  • Pitfall: Choosing a college solely based on its athletic program's prestige or reputation, without considering the overall fit academically, socially, and culturally.
  • Solution: Evaluate colleges holistically, considering academic programs, campus culture, and location in addition to the athletic program. Seek a balance that aligns with both academic and athletic goals.


4. Neglecting Communication Skills:

  • Pitfall: Poor communication with college coaches, including delayed responses, lack of initiative, or unprofessionalism, can create a negative impression.
  • Solution: Be proactive in reaching out to coaches, respond promptly to inquiries, and maintain clear and professional communication throughout the recruitment process.


5. Relying Solely on Highlight Reels:

  • Pitfall: Depending solely on highlight reels without providing context or additional information about skills, character, and work ethic.
  • Solution: Supplement highlight reels with detailed athletic resumes, academic transcripts, and recommendation letters. Showcase not just skills but also your commitment to teamwork and personal development.


By avoiding these pitfalls, student-athletes can enhance their chances of finding the right college fit both athletically and academically. It's crucial to approach the recruiting process with diligence, proactivity, and a well-rounded understanding of what each college can offer in terms of both sports and academics.


College Recruiting Coaches Pet Peeves

College coaches play a crucial role in the recruitment process, and certain behaviors can be perceived as pet peeves that may frustrate them. To ensure a positive and effective interaction, student-athletes should be mindful of the following potential pet peeves:


  1. Lack of Communication:
  • Pet Peeve: Coaches may be frustrated by student-athletes who fail to respond to emails, phone calls, or other communication promptly.
  • Solution: Maintain open lines of communication, respond promptly to inquiries, and demonstrate professionalism in all interactions.


2. Incomplete or Inaccurate Information:

  • Pet Peeve: Coaches may be annoyed by incomplete or inaccurate athletic profiles, transcripts, or other essential documents.
  • Solution: Provide coaches with accurate and comprehensive information, including academic transcripts, athletic achievements, and relevant personal details.


3. Unrealistic Expectations:

  • Pet Peeve: Coaches may be frustrated by student-athletes who have unrealistic expectations about scholarship offers, playing time, or the recruiting process in general.
  • Solution: Approach the process with realistic expectations, understanding that opportunities may vary, and be open to discussions with coaches about the potential fit for both parties.

4. Lack of Initiative:

  • Pet Peeve: Coaches may be irked by student-athletes who do not take the initiative in expressing genuine interest in the program or demonstrating a proactive approach to the recruitment process.
  • Solution: Show genuine interest in the program by attending showcases, visiting campuses, and reaching out to coaches with thoughtful questions.

5. Inconsistent Performance or Behavior:

  • Pet Peeve: Coaches may be concerned by inconsistencies in a student-athlete's performance, behavior, or commitment to both academics and athletics.
  • Solution: Demonstrate consistency in both performance and behavior on and off the field. Coaches value student-athletes who are reliable and committed to maintaining high standards.


By avoiding these pet peeves, student-athletes can build positive relationships with college coaches and increase their chances of a successful recruitment process. It's essential to approach interactions with coaches with professionalism, honesty, and a genuine interest in the program.


Strategies to Maximize Your College Recruiting Process


Maximizing the college recruiting process as a student-athlete involves a proactive and strategic approach. Here are key strategies to optimize your chances of finding the right fit:


  1.  Start Early
  • Begin the process early in high school. Research colleges, identify potential programs, and understand their athletic and academic requirements.

2. Build a Strong Athletic and Academic Profile:

  • Create a comprehensive athletic resume that includes key achievements, statistics, and highlight videos. Maintain a strong academic record to appeal to coaches and meet eligibility requirements.

3. Attend Showcases, Tournaments, Camps, and Clinics:

  • Participate in showcases, tournaments, and events where college coaches may be present. This provides an opportunity for coaches to see you in action and allows you to showcase your skills.

4. Proactive Communication:

  • Take the initiative to reach out to college coaches. Craft personalized emails expressing genuine interest in their program. Share your athletic achievements, academic goals, and reasons for wanting to join their team.

5. Create a Recruiting Video:

  • Develop a high-quality recruiting video showcasing your skills, versatility, and overall athleticism. Keep it concise and include relevant game footage, skills demonstrations, and highlights.

6. Utilize Online Recruiting Platforms:

  • Create profiles on online recruiting platforms where coaches actively search for potential recruits. Ensure your profiles are up-to-date with accurate information, including academic and athletic achievements.

7. Research and Evaluate Programs:

  • Research potential colleges thoroughly. Consider factors such as the coach's coaching style, team culture, academic offerings, and campus environment. Evaluate how well these align with your goals and preferences.

8. Attend College Camps and Visits:

  • Attend college camps or visit campuses to get a firsthand experience of the program and interact with the coaching staff. This demonstrates your genuine interest and allows coaches to assess your compatibility with the team.

9. Seek Guidance from Coaches:

  • Your coaches can be valuable resources in the recruiting process. Seek their guidance, ask for recommendations, and leverage their network to connect with college coaches.

10. Maintain a Professional Online Presence:

  • Ensure your social media profiles present you in a positive light. Coaches often check online presence as part of their evaluation process. Remove any content that may be perceived negatively.

11. Be Open-Minded and Flexible:

  • Be open to exploring various opportunities and consider programs that may not be widely known but align with your goals. Be flexible in adapting to different coaching styles and team dynamics.


By combining these strategies with dedication, perseverance, and a positive attitude, you can maximize your college recruiting process and increase the likelihood of finding the right collegiate athletic and academic fit.










By Chris Stack June 14, 2025
Are you prepared for the Recruiting Race? It's a marathon not a sprint.
By Chris Stack June 1, 2025
💡 What It Means to Be a SMART Recruit If you're a high school student-athlete with dreams of playing at the college level, you’ve probably heard how competitive and confusing the recruiting process can be. It’s true—navigating the world of college athletics, eligibility rules, academic requirements, communication with coaches, and scholarship opportunities can feel overwhelming. But here’s the good news: you don’t have to go through it blindly. Being a SMART Recruit means more than just athletic talent. It means you’re Educated , Empowered , Engaged , and Inspired . You take ownership of your journey by staying informed , organized , and committed to your future—both on and off the field. Let’s break it down. 🎓 Educated: Know the Landscape Smart Recruits take the time to understand the recruiting process. They know the rules, eligibility requirements, timelines, and what college coaches are looking for. They research the differences between NCAA Divisions I, II, III, NAIA, and NJCAA, and they understand how academics, athletics, and personal fit all play a role in finding the right school. Knowledge is power. When you're educated, you're able to avoid common mistakes, ask the right questions, and make informed decisions. 💪 Empowered: Own Your Journey Smart Recruits don’t wait for opportunity—they create it. They know that recruiting isn’t something that “just happens” to them. They take control by reaching out to coaches, attending the right events, and building a strong recruiting profile that reflects who they are as a student-athlete and a person. They recognize that no one will work harder for their future than they will . That sense of empowerment fuels their actions and keeps them moving forward—even when the journey gets tough. 🧠 Engaged: Be Proactive and Present The recruiting process is not passive—it requires you to stay active and engaged. Smart Recruits use tools like communication trackers, college lists, and visit checklists to stay on top of their outreach and deadlines. They’re not afraid to follow up, ask questions, and stay consistent. Being engaged means showing up: in your inbox, in the classroom, on the field, and in your mindset. Consistency beats luck every time. 🌟 Inspired: Stay Motivated by Your "Why" Every successful recruiting journey starts with a clear sense of purpose. Smart Recruits know why they’re pursuing college athletics, what they hope to achieve, and who they want to become in the process. That vision fuels their daily habits and decisions. Whether it's waking up early to train, studying late for a test, or rewriting an email to a coach—they’re motivated by a bigger goal and inspired to keep going, even when it’s hard. 🧭 Stay Informed. Stay Organized. Stay Ahead. Being a SMART Recruit also means staying informed about deadlines, program updates, and coach responses—and staying organized enough to manage it all. Whether you're managing communication, video links, or academic transcripts, having a system in place is crucial. That’s why tools like The Smart Recruit Tool Kit exist—to help you streamline the process, stay accountable, and make progress every week. 🎉 Coming Soon: The Smart Recruit Toolkit Get ready to take control of your college recruiting journey! The Smart Recruit —a comprehensive DIY toolkit designed to help student-athletes become educated, empowered, engaged, and inspired—will be launching soon. Packed with worksheets, templates, and expert guidance, this resource is your ultimate playbook to navigate the recruiting process with confidence and clarity. Stay tuned for the official launch! 🔚 Final Thought: Be the Recruit Coaches Want to Coach College coaches are looking for more than just athletic ability. They want students who are driven, self-aware, academically committed, and coachable. When you approach the process like a SMART Recruit , you show coaches you’re ready—not just to play at the next level, but to thrive there. ✅ Educated. ✅ Empowered. ✅ Engaged. ✅ Inspired. ✅ Informed & Organized. That’s what it means to be a SMART Recruit.
By Chris Stack May 12, 2025
Discover Your Why, Define Your Way
By Chris Stack May 5, 2025
How to Embrace the College Recruiting Process
By Chris Stack April 15, 2025
Unlock the College Athletics Landscape and Find the Right Path for You
By Chris Stack April 15, 2025
Tap Into Your Inner Jedi and Own the Recruiting Process
An aerial view of a football field in a stadium.
By Chris Stack April 4, 2025
The recruiting landscape for high school student-athletes is on the cusp of a significant transformation. Recent NCAA lawsuits and rulings have far-reaching implications that will change the way colleges recruit, distribute scholarships, and compensate athletes. As the dust settles, here's how these changes will impact the future of recruiting: Employee Status: A Game-Changer The recent ruling that grants employee status to college athletes will revolutionize the recruiting process. Colleges will now need to consider the financial and legal implications of employing student-athletes. This shift will likely lead to: - More emphasis on compensation packages and benefits - Changes in scholarship models and revenue sharing - Increased focus on athlete welfare and support services NCAA Athletes as Employees: Recent Ruling and Implications* A U.S. appeals court in Philadelphia ruled on July 11, 2024, that college athletes whose efforts primarily benefit their schools may qualify as employees deserving of pay under federal wage-and-hour laws ¹. This decision means that a test should be developed to differentiate between students who play college sports for fun and those whose effort "crosses the legal line into work" ¹. - Implications This ruling has significant implications for the NCAA and its long-standing concept of amateurism ¹. If athletes are considered employees, they may be entitled to compensation, benefits, and legal protections ². However, NCAA officials argue that this could harm student-athletes' experiences and create financial burdens for schools ¹. - Ongoing Debate: This issue is part of a broader debate about the rights and compensation of college athletes ². Some argue that athletes should be paid for their labor, while others believe that compensation could undermine the amateur nature of college sports ³. The National Labor Relations Board is also considering whether college athletes should be considered employees under federal labor law ². - Potential Consequences If athletes are classified as employees, schools and the NCAA may face substantial back pay claims from current and former athletes ⁴. This could lead to significant changes in the way college sports are structured and financed ². However, others argue that this could lead to unintended consequences, such as schools only funding profitable sports or detracting from the overall educational experience ². The Impact of New Ruling on Future College Rosters Reduced Roster Sizes Increased Injuries and Mental Health Issues Compensation and Benefits The impact of the new ruling on future college rosters is uncertain, with ongoing debates and discussions among coaches, administrators, and athletes ⁶. The new ruling's impact on future college rosters will likely unfold in the coming months and years. Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL): A New Recruiting Tool With the introduction of NIL guidelines, colleges can now use an athlete's marketability as a recruiting selling point. This will lead to: - Increased emphasis on social media presence and personal branding - Colleges highlighting their ability to help athletes build their NIL - More creative and lucrative endorsement opportunities Roster Size and Scholarship Implications Reduced roster sizes and changes in scholarship models will impact the number of available spots for incoming recruits. This will lead to: - Increased competition for fewer spots - More emphasis on early recruiting and commitments - Potential for more athletes to consider alternative routes like junior college or NAIA Recruiting Strategies: Adapting to the New Landscape Colleges will need to adapt their recruiting strategies to stay competitive. This may include: - Earlier identification and recruitment of top talent - More personalized and holistic approaches to recruiting - Increased focus on athlete development and support services The Student-Athlete Experience: A New Priority With the emphasis on athlete welfare and support services, colleges will need to prioritize the student-athlete experience. This will lead to: - Increased focus on academic support and resources - More emphasis on mental health and wellness programs - Colleges highlighting their commitment to athlete development and success beyond sports The future of recruiting high school student-athletes will be shaped by the evolving NCAA landscape. As colleges navigate these changes, they'll need to prioritize creative recruiting strategies, athlete welfare, and support services to attract top talent. Student-athletes, in turn, will need to be more proactive in their recruitment, considering factors beyond just athletic development. As the recruiting landscape continues to shift, one thing is certain – the future of college sports will be shaped by these transformative changes. Sources: Appeals court rules NCAA Athletes may qualify as employees - www.insidehighered.com NCAA Student-Athletes as Employees Case is Pandora's Box - news.bloomberglaw.com Are College Athletes "employees" of their school? - www.marketplace.org Pay to Play? Third Circuit Holds NCAA Athletes can be Considered Employees - www.littler.com 
A close up of a clock that shows the time as 4:20
By Chris Stack March 21, 2025
The journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step." - Lao Tzu
By Chris Stack February 10, 2025
Redefining Success in College Recruiting for Student-Athletes
Oprah winfrey is holding a microphone with her arms in the air
By Chris Stack January 17, 2025
If you've ever envisioned athletic scholarships being handed out as generously as Oprah's famous cars, it's time for a reality check. The journey to securing an athletic scholarship is far from the straightforward giveaway many imagine.
More Posts